More on growth and development

Just to carry on with the Friday discussion on growth and development, this weekend I read a bit more on development. The more I read on this topic the more I am amazed by the available literature. As I mentioned all kinds of factors have been discussed and widely researched and written (of which I have become aware recently, phew!!).

I read this paper by Rajan and Zingales where the central idea is that underdevelopment is due to initial factor endowments in the country. Their work is different from the earlier works that have looked at institutions, geography, religion, culture etc as factors for growth. Paper by R & Z offers more hope in the sense that where others look at factors which cannot be altered ( for instance what can a country do if it has adverse climatic conditions or has a difficult geographical landscape… ) or are difficult to alter (changing institutions its own time etc), R &Z explain factors that are more endogenous and hence can be altered…. the path to development is still a difficult one but there is more hope than offered by other papers.

By factor endowments they mean is that interests of certain groups (they call it constituencies) may not be aligned with each other and hence may oppose the reforms. The paper has some very interesting insights and has developed a very useful model which helps us understand if reforms are the key why don’t they happen…it is understood that in dictatorship reforms may not be allowed why is it that democracies fail to implement reforms (India is a classic case). So to get out of the trap, we need proper sequencing of reforms. The traditional advice “fix the institutions” may not work as what is needed is to make the endowments more equitable for reforms to take place.

The paper however is disappointing in one aspect… it doesn’t dwell in details how can endowments be changed? They attribute it to economic and non-economic factors which to me again look like fate more than anything else. They talk of non-economic factors like religion, nationalist movements etc. which have altered the initial factor endowments in countries. There are rich examples but still the problem persists.

But an interesting paper by all means. Another great stuff by this deadly combo!!

5 Responses to “More on growth and development”

  1. Applying academic work in practice « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] I can’t comment on the political side of the story but we can certainly pick some cues from the paper done by the deadly combo Rajan & Zingales which I blogged about here. […]

  2. Abhijeet Says:

    Hi,

    Some general comments first:
    1. Try to put more examples (e.g. Here” By factor endowments they mean is that interests of certain groups (they call it constituencies) may not be aligned with each other and hence may oppose the reforms” you could have given an example as this doesn’t make things very clear. Same applies to many other places.
    2. Try to make it more interesting by cutting extra flabs (i.e. adding too much of your own details).
    3. I don’t know why but your analysis seems less in content. Let me read more to give you specific feedback on this.

  3. Amol Agrawal Says:

    Ok, well examples should have been added I agree…but then one has to balance a blog…you just want to review the paper and say what it includes and what it doesn’t….

  4. Political Economy of Financial Development « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] paper reminded me of another superb paper by Rajan & Zingales which looks at underdevelopment from very similar […]

  5. Research on Globalisation and Monetary Policy « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] of globalization and has very direct implications for monetary policy, as recent events have shown.[10] Nor have we addressed the issue of international pricing, which is at the core of many debates in […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


%d bloggers like this: