Impossible Trinity: Basics and Facts

I am finding another source of learning apart from textbooks and academic papers- speeches. I am noticing the quality of speeches by policymakers is getting better by the day. So much so, I have put a seperate link in my blog to cover speeches.

Here is another excellent speech (summary is here) by BIS Deputy General Manager, Hervé Hannoun. He discusses impossible trinity and helps understand it by providing case studies of Asian-Pacific nations.

What is Impossible Trinity? Wikipedia explains:

….the hypothesis in international economics that it is not possible to have

  • A fixed exchange rate
  • Free capital movement
  • An independent monetary policy

Suppose a country is growing and in order to grow further would need to  increase its investments. So far, its savings have been enough and now it needs foreign savings as well. As a result, the policymakers liberalise capital flows (inwards and outtwards) in the country. Given this choice, the hypothesis says the country can either look at exchange rate stability or price stability but not both. Why?

Now suppose, the country is Japan whose currency is yen (“this is just an example”) and it has both objectives price and exchange rate stability. To achieve former, it maintains fixed exchange rate and for latter, it maintains an inflation target (implicit or explicit).

  • As capital inflows are allowed, foreign investors take exposure in Japan and bring their dollars, convert it into yen and invest it.
  • As a result the demand for domestic currency goes up. Ideally as demand goes up so should the price meaning exchange rate should appreciate (or go up from Rs 45 per dollar to say 40)
  • But as currency is fixed, the Central bank needs to maintain the level and instead gives the foreign borrower the desired yen and keeps the dollars with itself.
  • Now, as supply of yen increases in the economy so does inflation (too much money chasing few goods). As inflation stability is also an objective the entire thing comes on its head, hence the impossibility of making all 3 objectives work together.
  • Note that higher inflation can also be controlled by sterilizing the flows i.e. Central Banks issue govt. securities and suck the money supply. But that means more expenditure for government and is not a long-term solution as govts are supposed to direct their expenditure towards enhancing capital base of the country and not for monetary and exchange rate stability.

So after some concepts, let us get back to the speech. On Page 4, it has a table that summarises what each Asia-Pacific nation is doing. Some e.g.

Hong Kong, with open capital markets and a currency board, implicitly accepts foreign monetary policy, which can at times be too tight or too easy. The fixed exchange rate provides a stable environment for importers and exporters.

Countries such as Australia and New Zealand have chosen domestic price stability in the form of an inflation target, and accept a high degree of exchange rate volatility.

India has a multiple indicators approach and looks at everything.

As surging capital flows is a problem with most, he goes on to discuss the possible solutions to contriol the situation which are straight from textbook:

1. Allow curreny to appreciate
2. Intervene to prevent appreciation
3. Impose retrictions on capital flows

Then he cites evidence that Asian countries generally have been reluctant to let their country appreciate. Meaning given the two choices after allowing for capital flows , they have preferred to keep exchange rates stable and have not allowed them to appreciate.

Countries like Korea, NZ and Philippines have inflation targets and capital flows have been a problem with them. Ideally we should have seen some appreciation in these countries.

Now, see the table on Page 10. It shows currency has appreciated only in India, Korea and China (now, China is a surprise) from 1994 levels.

This is what makes the entire learning so good. You not only know what impossible trinity is, you also know which country is doing what?

The consensus in economic circles is that have free capital inflows, and have a stable monetary policy & let the currency float. His speech also discusses the same and suggests ways in which Asia-Pacific nations can move towards floating/flexible exchange rates.

Super stuff. Highly recommended. 

Update:

I have  written two papers on the subject, one a general overview on Impossible Trinity and two, a specific report on how RBI is managing the Impossible trinity.

20 Responses to “Impossible Trinity: Basics and Facts”

  1. Madhav Says:

    Very good read.
    Many thanks
    Madhav

  2. Inflation Targeting and Impossible Trinity « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] Targeting and Impossible Trinity I had written some days ago on impossible trinity. It covered a speech from BIS Deputy GM who explains the […]

  3. A good summary on Asian Financial Crisis « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] pointed this issue earlier as […]

  4. Literature Survey on Capital Controls « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] emerging market economies. It is leading to the Central Banks of these economies managing the impossible trinity. As neither monetary policy nor exchange rate management wished to be left to market forces, […]

  5. Financial deepening without financial excesses « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] speeches. I covered his previous speech on how Asian economies are managing their capital flows here and in a research paper […]

  6. isaac Says:

    Is possible to know the money stock in all the world valued at single currency? are CBK’s playing their role?

  7. Vijay Says:

    Very well worded and put across. Kudos

  8. faulkner Says:

    Strangely the browser I have does not display your post properly… Are you sure this post has been set up for Safari? Would be nice if you could double check your code, although it might come from some wrong settings on my side

  9. Mostly Economics – 2010 in review « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] Impossible Trinity: Basics and Facts August 2007 8 comments 5 […]

  10. Rakshit Says:

    Good one .

  11. Happy New Year wishes to all and Mostly Economics 2011 in review « Mostly Economics Says:

    […]  Impossible Trinity: Basics and Facts 10 comments August 2007 […]

  12. Personal Loans Without A Credit Check Says:

    I hardly comment, but i did a few searching and wound up here Impossible Trinity: Basics
    and Facts Mostly Economics. And I do have a couple of questions for you if it’s allright. Could it be just me or does it seem like a few of these remarks come across as if they are coming from brain dead visitors? 😛 And, if you are posting on other sites, I would like to keep up with anything fresh you have to post. Would you list of every one of all your communal sites like your linkedin profile, Facebook page or twitter feed?

  13. Steffi Says:

    Thanks a lot for this. You made it really simple. Much appreciated.

  14. » what is better for a strong economy? A strong currency or a weak currency? Says:

    […] monetary policy to adjust for economic conditions: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impossible_trinity https://mostlyeconomics.wordpress.com/2007/08/21/impossible-trinity-basics-and-facts/ […]

  15. paper rifle targets Says:

    Wonderful goods from you, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you are just extremely wonderful. I really like what you have acquired here, really like what you’re stating and the way
    in which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still care for to keep it wise.
    I can’t wait to read much more from you. This is really a tremendous site.

  16. how to fly a quadcopter Says:

    What’s up, I want to subscribe for this weblog to take hottest updates, therefore where can i do
    it please help out.

  17. premium pure forskolin 250 mg Says:

    Thanks designed for sharing such a pleasant idea, article is fastidious, thats why i have read it entirely

  18. Kia Says:

    Thanks , I have just been searching for info about this topic
    for ages and yours is the best I have found out so far.
    However, what concerning the bottom line? Are you sure concerning
    the supply?

  19. Servicio Tecnico Indesit Madrid Says:

    Nosostros somos servicio técnico de lavadoras Otsein, estamos listos para la reparación de sus electrodomésticos en Barrio del Pilar Madrid y alrededores el mismo día de la solicitud. La reparación de electrodomésticos en Barrio del Pilar Madrid se realizara en el domicilio del solicitante del servicio, realizando previamente un presupuesto de la reparación. Nuestras reparaciones en Barrio del Pilar Madrid están garantizadas por escrito en los materiales empleados como en la mano de obra. Venta, instalación, reparación y mantenimiento de BOMBAS, GRUPOS DE PRESIÓN, SONDEOS.

  20. Impossible Trilemma or Dilemma? | Site Title Says:

    […] https://mostlyeconomics.wordpress.com/2007/08/21/impossible-trinity-basics-and-facts/ […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


%d bloggers like this: