A request to India’s Ivy Leagues- show us some research

It is March and the media is rife with developments on the placement scenario in India’s elite Business Schools. The placement season has begun and news is filtering on the compensation packages received at the various schools. The news of who and which school has received the highest compensation package is doing the rounds.

I still don’t understand this placement mania in the media. One can understand a weekly column to cover the issue but we see a regular full page dedicated to the events. It is sad that the only way these elite colleges engage the media is on the placement prospects. Is that the only thing that these education temples have to offer?

The most important parameter for a good school is its quality of research and unfortunately, this is something we never get to read. Unlike the west, where the media profiles faculties and their research, all we get to hear from these schools is on placements.

An important way one can judge the quality of research is via peer reviews. The academia makes references to other people’s work in their research and more such references, better is the quality of the research. Though this practice has been abused lately but is still the best way to judge the quality of a research. It is actually surprising that after reading many a research papers (even on Indian economy), you hardly come across a reference that comes from these elite schools. Whenever one comes across an Indian name it is mostly from a foreign university.

There is a huge interest on Indian economy and some Universities have even set up India centers. So, the faculty can’t even blame “times” saying no one is interested in Indian economy/companies etc. The academia can’t even blame the media saying it isn’t interested in covering research. These days awe come across a lot of newspaper articles that explain the developments using research papers. Some newspapers even have dedicated columns profiling research but it mostly covers research done in Universities abroad. Infact, one leading economist who writes a column lamented on the same fact- lack of research in India.

Then there are other events that these schools organize – seminars, symposiums, conferences etc. to discuss various research papers on a particular topic. There is hardly any mention of the same in the media. All we get to read is about the cultural festivals and marketing events.

This is not to say that the faculties do not research but they need to use better ways to propagate their research. They should make efforts to use web and print media to inform people about the new research undertaken in these schools. It is very good if the faculty can get their research published in leading journals but discussing it with the public is be an equally good first step.

The elite schools may not realise but they have led to development of a very dangerous precedent. All the schools seem to be just focused on placements and not on the curriculum. The students also take up a course looking at the lucre and not understanding the suitability. The students should ask their respective schools what they can teach not how much salaries they can help them get.

It is a request that the elite schools take up this matter seriously and lead from the front. They should limit all these press releases on salaries and placements and instead channelise their energies on showcasing their research output. At the end, I wanted to point to an interesting trivia. The financial assistance for one the most profound idea in economics – The Market for Lemons written by George Akerlof – was given by Indian Statistical Institute. So, it is not that the Indian schools can’t do it, all they need is to re-focus.

Advertisements

11 Responses to “A request to India’s Ivy Leagues- show us some research”

  1. Where is the research? at Blogbharti Says:

    […] Amol Agarwal asks elite Indian business schools and universities to showcase their research efforts too: I still don’t understand this placement mania in the media. One can understand a weekly column to cover the issue but we see a regular full page dedicated to the events. It is sad that the only way these elite colleges engage the media is on the placement prospects. Is that the only thing that these education temples have to offer? […]

  2. HmmBut Says:

    Lot of bad news on India in ft.com

    What’s your personal opinion? You are on the scene.

    The property market may have already topped:
    http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/d3078eb0-f765-11dc-ac40-000077b07658.html

  3. rahul Says:

    ..completely agree with you..I guess the $$$ salaries are blown out of proportions…no real developmental and path breaking work is beingc done in indian schools…everyone is riding just to get a ticket in some fancy MNC

  4. IFMR - a great research institute « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] had earlier raised an issue over India’s elite management schools just focused on placement and not […]

  5. Raghuram Rajan Committee on Financial Sector reforms « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] three, I didn’t find a single paper from India’s elite business schools. I had earlier raised this point that these institutes don’t point to their research. You hardly come across any of their […]

  6. Deciphering the B-school ranking in India « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] is the quality of research. Here, the main (perhaps only) criteria is placements. There is hardly any research by anyone in India. I haven’t come across one paper from these elite schools being referred […]

  7. In search of home grown economists and phd education « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] Prof (if at all) mentioned as a reference by anyone even for research in India (See my post here).  In case for any policy design, the reliance on foreign economists becomes but natural. And then […]

  8. A peek into eco research at Indian Ivy Leagues/ Think tanks « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] would reiterate to India’s  Ivy leagues to shore up their research. The quality of research needs a serious […]

  9. Indian academia salaries- Too low or too high? « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] being paid too much. For instance, just look at the research done by academia in India. Even in the elite colleges, we hardly have any research to take note of. The college rankings hardly include things like […]

  10. Geography of Economic Research and why India is a laggard in eco research? « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] dearth of good economic research in the country. Check any University’s economics department, Ivy League’s Working Papers, Think tanks working papers. You may get quantity but quality is not good enough. Even committees […]

  11. Dismal state of managment research in India « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] graduate and under-graduate schools in the country. But as this blog has repeatedly said (here, here), things are pretty bad at higher level as well.    We are judging an institute solely on the […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


%d bloggers like this: