Fitch downgrades Indian currency, who downgrades fitch?

There has been a lot of speculation for many days now that credit rating agencies would downgrade India ratings.

Fitch was the first and it downgraded local currency default rating from Stable to Negative. The overall rating stays the same at BBB-. The press release says (requires a free login):

The revision to the local currency Outlook is based on a considerable deterioration in the central government’s fiscal position in 2008-09 (FY09), combined with a notable increase in government debt issuance to finance subsidies not captured in the budget,” said James McCormack, Head of Asia Sovereign ratings.

Fitch forecasts the central government deficit may increase from 2.8% of GDP in FY08 to 4.5% of GDP in FY09 based in part on higher on-budget subsidies, interest payments and public wages. The agency expects bonds issued to oil and fertiliser companies to reach at least 2% of GDP this year, implying an underlying central government deficit of 6.5% of GDP or higher.

The markets reacted and fell across all kinds of markets.

The higher  fiscal deficit has been one of the weakest links in Indian economy for a long time and there is no surprise. I also calculated the off-balance sheet items and clearly it makes the entire fiscal deficit much larger than reported.

However, what is ironical is Fitch downgrades India but we don’t have any mechanism to downgrade Fitch itself? I am sure Moody’s and S&P will follow as well and we all know their role in the recent sub-prime mess. Should these ratings continue to be so important that they lead to a bloodbath in markets? The markets clearly seem to be valuing them still despite they failing time and again to safeguard the markets.

Addendum:

I had some more thoughts. Just imagine Fitch sayinga after a few years that India downgrade on this date was due to a modelling error!!

On a serious note, I also didn’t see any of the anchors on various business television channels raise the issues pertaining to these credit rating agencies. Why couldn’t anyone say shouldn’t the raters set their house in order first? Instead. there was a big hue and cry over the entire downgrade.

I am not saying that fiscal deficit is not a problem. It surely is but again, it has always been a problem with India. Still the foreign money kept poring in.

3 Responses to “Fitch downgrades Indian currency, who downgrades fitch?”

  1. » Fitch downgrades Indian currency, who downgrades fitch? Says:

    […] M0 wrote an interesting post today onHere’s a quick excerpt There has been a lot of speculation for many days now that credit rating agencies would downgrade India ratings. Fitch was the first and it downgraded local currency default rating from Stable to Negative. The overall rating stays the same at BBB-. The press release says (requires a free login): The revision to the local currency Outlook is based on a considerable deterioration in the central government’s fiscal position in 2008-09 (FY09), combined with a notable increase in government debt […]

  2. Fitch downgrades rupee, India downgrades Fitch « India dispatch Says:

    […] Mostly Economics, made a good point when questioning the authority of Fitch’s ratings after it admitted it had […]

  3. Credit rating agencies make merry eitherways « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] they could be making it worse for economies as well. The ratings are procyclical. The question of who rates these agencies is as important as restructuring financial […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


%d bloggers like this: