Is criticising Japanese policies of 1990s crisis fair?

I came across this wonderful speech by Kazuo Ueda of  University of Tokyo. The speech was given in 2001 and Ueda was then a member of Policy Board of Japan.

He points Japan’s monetary policy was far more aggressive then experts think.

I left my career in academia to become a member of the Policy Board, the highest decision-making body of the Bank of Japan (BOJ), in 1998. Since then, I have received various policy recommendations from academics, which I greatly appreciated, but I must say that some of them were based on misapprehensions due to insufficient knowledge of the actual economic situation and monetary policy. On the other hand, many in the academic world are clearly discontented with the BOJ’s allegedly timid approach to monetary easing. Filling the gap between the views of the BOJ and the academic world is not easy, but I hope my speech today will contribute to better understanding between the two.

He then takes you to understand that BoJ was quite aggressive and tried all the tricks in the book to avoid deflation and liquidity trap. There are 3 policy options when interest rates are near zero.

Three options for further monetary easing can be considered when money market interest rates are near zero. First, if the short-term rate is very low but not zero percent, the rate can be lowered further to as close to zero as possible by increasing the monetary base. Second, the BOJ can influence expectations of economic entities by promising to continue monetary easing into the future. Some have called this the commitment or policy duration effect. Third, the BOJ can carry out unconventional operations by purchasing assets other than short-term Japanese government securities.

Read the speech to get some ‘from the ground’ experience in Japan. The things just did not improve in Japan and kept getting worse.The speech points that if deflation like situation happens it is very difficult to reverse it. There are policy prescriptions but getting them to work is a different challenge altogether.

And this is why this speech is a worry. Though, economists may never agree that US faces a situation like Japan but the similarity is getting closer. In Japan it started with the banking sector and went on to impact the entire economy. The banking sector had huge exposures to real estate sector and had huge NPAs. What was also seen in Japan was the huge presence of Zombie lending. The US banking sector may be far more competitive but the balance-sheet picture of both Japanese and US banks (and other developed economies)  is likely to be similar – huge losses and need for substantial capital.

The positive this time is unlike Bank of Japan, Fed has reacted much faster. It did see the lessons from Japan but was never sure how bad the problem was.  So, though Fed may have acted faster the overall situation in US Banks looks to be much worse than Japan.  Let’s see what happens.

6 Responses to “Is criticising Japanese policies of 1990s crisis fair?”

  1. What is liquidity trap? « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] shaping expectations is what is very difficult to do as Kazuo Ueda points in Japan’s case. The policies should be credible enough which leads to positive inflation […]

  2. INMACO Goes Down Under | Working in Oil and Gas Says:

    […] Australian market since the 1990s, working on several …Blogs That May Also be of interest 1990sIs criticising Japanese policies of 1990s crisis fair? « Mostly …CIA helped Peru shoot down 15 planes for drugs in late 1990s …'Irrational Exuberance' of […]

  3. Coordinating financial stability in EU and price stability in Germany « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] similar lines, I am still amazed why Bank of Japan could not shape inflationary expectations despite much easing and a commitment to generate the same. BoJ is criticised for being slow and […]

  4. What if Japan had helicopter-dropped money on its economy? « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] Anyways, an excellent paper which tries to walk the talk. Am not sure whether the walk would have worked? […]

  5. THUS - because it does not have to be that way Says:

    […] a result of such evasions, uncannily similar to those of the Japanese in the 1990s, it looks more and more likely that we’ll follow the same path, from a credit crunch into a […]

  6. Decline in Productivity key to Japan’s lost decade? « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] Decline in Productivity key to Japan’s lost decade? By Amol Agrawal Whatever research I have read on Japan’s lost decade  I always thought the reason for crisis was – asset market boom (with rising real estate and equity prices), banks lending to the real estate companies and other zombie corporations. Once the house prices fell, all things collapsed. We are seeing the same events in US and other economies whose fin firms were linked to US housing markets. That is why we often compare the 2 events. And then the policy moves deepened the recession (though Japanese policymakers don’t agree, see this as well) […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: