Linking agri productivity of India, Peru and France

Dani Rodrik has a superb post on the same.

He along with co-researchers discovers  U-shaped pattern of agri productivity:

What it shows is that the relative productivity of agriculture exhibits a U-shaped pattern over the course of development. It first falls and then rises, as countries get richer. (By productivity, I am referring to labor productivity.)

You can see the same pattern within countries as well. Here is a chart that collates the trends in three countries at different levels of development: India, Peru, and France.

See the chart. It shows agri productivity declining for India, stagnant for Peru and rising for France:

In India, which is the poorest country, as overall productivity has increased, the productivity of agriculture (relative to other activities in the economy) has come down steadily. In France, the richest country, agricultural productivity has converged with that of the rest of the economy. In Peru, which is somewhere in between, the relative productivity of agriculture has fluctuated around the minimum point of the U-curve.

Findings are two-fold:

What these results point to are two critical dynamics that take place during the course of development. First, you need some new, high-productivity activities to emerge in order for development to happen. These typically arise outside of agriculture. So as these new activities propel the economy forward, agriculture falls behind in terms of relative productivity. Second, labor tends to move from low- to high-productivity activities as an economy gets richer. This tends to reduce the gap between productivity in agriculture and non-agriculture (think of diminishing marginal returns). At some point, the second dynamic overwhelms the first, and the curve begins to slope outward.

Lesson: economic development requires both new activities (diversification) and ongoing transfer of resources from traditional to modern activities. Some countries are stuck with no new industries, so they never grow. Others get a few new industries (e.g. mining and other natural resource-based industries), but these do not expand sufficiently and absorb much labor, so development gets stuck at an intermediate level of income. The real successful countries are those that pull off both tricks.

In India’s case, first is happening with new industries like IT, telecom etc rising. But still not much shift from agri to productive industry happening. Will be interesting to see how long it takes for India to complete the U-curve of agri productivity.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: