Are high inflation expectations in India getting entrenched and ignored?

This blog has made many a posts for this aspect. Inflation despite being so high is hardly a cause for concern.

Arvind Subramanian of PIIE says taming inflation may prove difficult because the social consensus in favour of moderate inflation appears to have eroded:

Today, three aspects about inflation in India are worrisome. It is unprecedentedly high. It may have been the key proximate cause of the recent rupee crisis. And taming it may prove difficult because the social consensus in favour of moderate inflation has eroded. Consider each.

It being high..India is Latinised. This is perhaps India’s first inflation crisis:

First, inflation has been historically high not in absolute terms but relative to the rest of the world, which is both striking and unrecognised. Figure 1 (top line) shows that high as Indian inflation been recently, it was actually higher in two previous episodes: the late 1970s and late-80s to the early 1990s. But the lower line ofFigure 1 shows that since 2008, Indian inflation has not only been greater than in comparable low and middle income countries but the differential is a staggering unprecedented 4-5 percentage points. India as a paragon and beacon of price stability amongst the developing world is history. India is now Latinised, although ironically Latin America itself has moved on. (Click for graphics)

Second. The relationship between CAD and inflation:

Second, the role of inflation in the recent crisis is best understood in light of something unusual that happened in the run-up to it. India’scurrent account deficit (CAD) surged even as growth started decelerating. For about 10 quarters, growth declined but the current account increased from about 1.5 per cent of gross domestic product (GDP) to over 5 per cent (Figure 2). The pattern in most emerging market crises is for growth to surge that sucks in imports, leading to higher CADs. This growth surge can either be fuelled by government spending (India in 1991 or Latin America in the 1980s) or by private spending (Asia in the late 1990s, and emerging Europe in the 2000s). The flip side is that growth declines should lead to falling imports and improving current account positions. This did not happen.

That fiscal deficits did not strictly drive the deterioration in the external deficit is illustrated in Figure 3. The CAD started deteriorating from 2003 onwards even though the fiscal deficit declined well until 2007. And after 2009, the fiscal deficit wobbles while the CAD surges relentlessly.

In fact, as Figure 4 shows, since the early 2000s, there is a striking correlation between inflation and the CAD. This correlation is not spurious because of the plausible transmission mechanism from high inflation to reduced financial savings and higher gold imports that rendered the CAD unmanageably high. Between 2007 and 2011, household savings declined from over 12 per cent of GDP to under 9 per cent.

Third and even more important the casual approach to fixing inflation:

If high and persistent inflation is thus a key culprit, shouldn’t policy be focused on reducing it quickly and durably? Yes, but that will not prove easy. Three factors suggest that the social consensus in favour of moderate inflation has been steadily eroding. It has long been a law of Indian political economy that inflation above 5 per cent makes incumbent politicians nervous because voters care about price stability. That seems to have changed.

Of course, the mere fact that inflation is higher than elsewhere is not proof of the demise of that social consensus. What it suggests is that in the past, periods of high inflation occurred when global inflation was high, so India had inevitably to “import” some of that high global inflation. Now the situation is unique: arguably, the first truly home-grown inflation crisis that has lasted many years now (since 2008) and yet little done to combat it.

Second, recent work by Milan Vaishnav of the Carnegie Endowment for International Peace provides interesting evidence. In the 1980s and 1990s, state election outcomes were negatively correlated with inflation: higher the inflation, worse the electoral prospects for incumbents. In the 2000s, however, voters seemed to care more about growth and not at all about high inflation. The revolution of rising expectations has become all about maintaining high growth, not about restoring moderate inflation.

Third, there is the surprising “dog-that-did-not-bark” phenomenon. Since 2008, while there has been sporadic outrage against spikes in vegetable and onion prices, there has just not been the consistent chorus of clamour against high inflation. The liberal elite has been more pre-occupied with growth than inflation. And the voices of the poor too have been muffled possibly because rural wages have risen more rapidly than inflation. Evidently, inflation has become a crime with many actual, but few perceived, victims.

Middle class has nearly exited from the several chaos in the country. Much of media is full of people for whom inflation is just a number..

Because of the election bit, government has also become casual towards inflation and does not really penalise RBI Governor.

In the past, the job of the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) governor tended to be relatively easy because delivering on RBI’s mandate of low inflation commanded political and social support. The interests of North Block and Mint Road were broadly aligned. But the growth boom of the 2000s changed all that. Pursuing growth was privileged over slaying high inflation. In August last year, when growth began to fall below 5 to 6 per cent and, critically, when this deceleration began to seem more permanent, panic galvanised policymakers into reform action.

But high and sustained inflation has never elicited a comparably robust policy response. It is noteworthy that the RBI governor’s rushed statement last week had relatively little to say about inflation on the very day that the data signalled rising inflation pressures (from already high levels). More broadly, the anaemic response to low inflation is reflected in the fact that the policy rate adjusted for inflation has been negative – and significantly so – all through the recent episode of high inflation. And that is true even after the two recent hikes of the repo rate by the new governor.

This is a really important point. The current FM chided former RBI Governor many times for not lowering rates. Hardly any rebuke for failure to lower inflation. Moreover, now the FM feels RBI can do nothing about inflation. He is perhaps happier with the new Governor as he keeps giving growth boosting (stock markets too) talks while keeping inflation on the sidelines. The inflation word is just mentioned to keep the credentials intact. Nothing more to it. There is hardly any worry, any press release when inflation keeps printing high numbers. We do get statements when markets decline a bit..

Problems of plenty for people affected by inflation…Neither policy nor public cares much about it…

2 Responses to “Are high inflation expectations in India getting entrenched and ignored?”

  1. överkomligt Fotboll jerseys Says:

    trackback

    [ … ] Hela utseendet i din hemsida är magnifika , låt väl som innehåll material [ … ]

  2. MAZ Says:

    The solution to inflation is to simply stop inflating. The monetary inflation of rupee my the RBI runs around 7%. This devalues the rupee at 7% every year. And as soon as the prices adjust to the new volume of additional rupees in the economy, they rise. And so CPI is also around 7%.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


%d bloggers like this: