Why does ban on child labor increases child labor..

Prashant Bharadwaj, Leah Lakdawala and Nicholas Li explain this puzzle in this voxeu column.

They say the ban increases the supply of child labor as wages decline:

What effect do child-labour bans have in practice? In a comprehensive review in a 2007 article, Eric Edmonds concludes that “despite all this policy discussion, there does not appear to be any study of the effectiveness of restrictions on work that would meet current standards of evidence.”

In order to fill this critical gap in the literature, we use individual-level data from national employment surveys to study the impact of India’s flagship legislation against child labour – the Child Labour Prohibition and Regulation Act of 1986. Although the 1986 Act was not the first child-labour law enacted in India, it put in place a more uniform and stricter code, and most recent articles in the press cite this law as the starting point for legal action against child labour in India. The Act targeted children under the age of 14.

  • We show that after the ban, overall employment levels of children under the legal working age of 14 (relative to those of legal age) rose, rather than fell.

Children under 14 are 1.7 percentage points more likely to work after the ban; given that around 14% of children under 14 were employed before the ban, this amounts to a 12% increase in child employment. This seems to stem in part from the large drop in child wages, which fall by nearly 4% relative to adult wages after the ban. The decrease in child wages is particularly large in the manufacturing sector – the sector targeted by the ban itself.

When we focus on children with siblings in the 10-13 age group – those who are likely to be affected by the ban – we find they are about 5.6% more likely to be pushed into work in response to the ban.

  • In line with the theoretical predictions from Basu (2005), the effects seem to be concentrated among the poorest families – those whose head of the household has less than a secondary education, and whose food consumption is largely made up of cheap calories from staple foods.

Moreover, we find some evidence that children are being taken out of school in order to work. Children with siblings age 10-13 are less likely to be in school after the ban. Finally, we show that other key components of household welfare, such as per capita expenditure and assets, seem to decrease slightly after ban. This suggests that overall the ban may have made households worse-off.

Policy implications:

Perhaps most relevant to our findings, in February 2013 a bill was introduced to the Parliament of India calling for the abolition of all forms of child labour. Among other provisions, the proposed bill also calls for increased monitoring and punishment for violators of such laws. The results of our paper caution against such policies in the presence of broader institutional and market failures.

Our findings do not discourage all forms of government-led policies against child labour. There are many options available to policymakers who wish to reduce the incidence of child labour, such as cash transfers to families, and increasing investments in education. If anything, we think a discussion in policy circles about these alternatives should be heightened since it appears from our study that child-labour bans of the type instituted under the Child Labour Prohibition and Regulation Act of 1986 can be ineffective.

Just like most other bans, this ban too has unintended consequences. As Prof. Gary Becker has shown how families (sadly) look at children as assets and look forward to them for boosting their family incomes. One needs to look at this problem of child labor from a more holistic perspective. There are many adverse societal interlinkages present..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: