Archive for April 6th, 2015

Book Review – MS: A Life in Music

April 6, 2015

This is just a brilliant book by TJS George. It is a bio of MS. Subbulaxmi but is  much more than just a personal sketch.

It has an amazing introduction & discussion and Carnatic music and social life in TN. The way music was shaped in TN and became such an important part of their lives is quite a story. The various caste and community equations and how MS overcame all this, is really a fascinating read. Then there is politics as well.


Mudra Bank – new regime, old philosophy..

April 6, 2015

Debashis Basu reflects on the decision to create a new bank  – MUDRA bank.  He wonders the obsession to create new financial instis in each new govt:

For some strange reason, every new government wants to launch a new bank, or a major financial institution and multiple financial products. Previous governments have been responsible for superfluous organisations like IDFC with headquarters in Chennai, the Bharatiya Mahila Bank in 2013, the Rajiv Gandhi Equity Scheme, etc.

The Narendra Modi government, following the same path, may well outdo previous governments, because Mr Modi, like Indira Gandhi, believes the government alone can “fix” the many problems India has. In just 10 months, the government has launched Jan Dhan Yojana with a lot of fanfare and a financial product called the Sukanya Samriddhi Scheme in January this year. On April 8, probably with as much fanfare and full-page ads in newspapers, the government will announce the launch of the Micro Units Development and Refinance Agency (Mudra) Bank.

Is there a need for Mudra Bank? Well, arguments can always be cooked up to support a direct government intervention to solve any one of our many chronic problems. One such problem is inequitable availability of finance. Too much of capital goes to large companies and too little to small businessmen. This is unfortunate because study after study has proved that not only are smaller borrowers more honest in repaying debt, but collectively they have a huge economic impact.

Mudra Bank will be another such attempt:

Mudra Bank will be a Rs 20,000-crore institution, which would “primarily be responsible for refinancing all micro-finance institutions which are in the business of lending to micro and small business entities”. It will be supported by an additional Rs 3,000 crore from the Budget to create a credit guarantee corpus to guaranteeing loans being provided to the micro enterprises. It would partner with state-/regional-level coordinators to provide finance to the “last-mile financier” of small and micro business enterprises. Not to forget that it will “primarily be responsible for laying down policy guidelines for micro/small enterprise financing business; registration, regulation and accreditation/rating of MFI entities; laying down responsible financing practices to ward off indebtedness and ensure proper client protection principles and methods of recovery”.

It would also be “responsible for the development of a standardised set of covenants governing last-mile lending to micro/small enterprises; promoting right technology solutions for the last mile; formulating and running a credit guarantee scheme and creating a good architecture of last-mile credit delivery to micro businesses under the scheme of Pradhan Mantri Mudra Yojana.”

Phew! So Mudra Bank will be a lender, consultant, regulator, think tank and an agent of social change, all rolled in one. Unfortunately, if this is what Mudra Bank is supposed to be, it will suffer from a congenital defect at birth: too many conflicting objectives – something that beset Unit Trust of India earlier and still affects government-controlled banks and insurance companies. This is how all public sector units used to be conceived. Clearly, the babus who have drawn up the Mudra Bank seem to belong to the 1970s, too, not just the idea.

There have been so many in the past:

But wait a minute. What can Mudra Bank do that can’t be done now with some tweaking of the existing system? I dug around a bit and discovered, to my horror, that successive governments have focused on microlending for decades. As a result, the has already inherited a massive bureaucracy and welfare system meant for small businessmen. This includes:

  • Small Industries Development Bank of India
  • National Small Industries Corporation
  • National Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development
  • Credit Guarantee Scheme
  • Priority sector lending by all banks
  • Regional rural banks
  • Bharatiya Mahila Bank
  • National Scheduled Castes Finance and Development Corporation
  • National Scheduled Tribes Finance and Development Corporation
  • National Backward Classes Finance and Development Corporation
  • 18 State Financial Corporations
  • 25 State Industrial Development Corporations
  • Microfinance programmes
  • Assistance to Entrepreneurship Development Institutes
  • National Innovation Foundation
  • A Rs 10,000-crore fund announced in the 2014 Budget for promoting entreprneurship.

Mudra Bank will be backed by a Rs 3,000-crore credit guarantee scheme. But a credit guarantee scheme is already functioning for the past decade. Till August 31, 2014, cumulatively 1,599,128 proposals from micro and small enterprises have been approved for guarantee cover for aggregate credit of Rs 79,647.15 crore.

There are at least three ministries now involved in helping small business in some way or the other: finance; micro, small and medium enterprises; and a new ministry of skill development and entrepreneurship; apart from ministries like tribal affairs and social justice running their own sectarian schemes for tribals and scheduled castes, respectively. I may have missed a few more organisations and the many departmental schemes that try to put money extorted from taxpayers, into the pockets of chosen people.

This array of government companies, schemes and initiatives overseen by a vast bureaucracy, based on some warped but failed notion of government-delivered equity, was not enough for Mr Modi. He had to set up a new bank, another new bureaucracy, borrowing ideas of the 1970s, even as there is no accountability for taxpayers’ money already wasted on numerous initiatives to “support” small businesses of various kinds. And this from a regime that had promised minimum government. What a shame!

We have anyways made too much out of the change. All that is happening is packaging old wine in new bottle. Both central bank and government’s obsession with creating new banking organisations shows neglect/ignorance of India’s financial history. We moved form a highly differentiated banking structure to a consolidated one only to move back to differentiated one..

Just new names are being added to the old (shall we say rejected) ideas..

A tongue-in-cheek look at economics and society…

April 6, 2015

EPW has a new column which will occasionally look at such interesting pieces. It is written by Toothcomber which is the pseudonym of an officially retired economist musically disinclined to rationality. 🙂

‘Toothcomber’ is intellectually descended from ‘Beachcomber,’ which was pen name of the English columnist J B Morton who presided over the Daily Express’ ‘By the Way’ column from 1924 to 1975. The present column has been stimulated partly by the kindly thought that an economics magazine deserves a regular dose of solid economics in it, and partly by the realisation that even if one were to deliberately set about doing a J B Morton on Economics, it might prove hard to come up with anything that could quite parallel some of the stuff that professionals in the field have been systematically dishing out—as mimicked in various minuscule pieces which Morton wrote on the subject, with titles such as ‘The Money Market,’ ‘Financial Note’, etc. ‘Economics: The View from Above’ is an irregular offering whose presiding spirit will be the philosopher Harry Frankfurt’s book On Bullshit. If any part of anything written here is found to make any sense to any reader who is not an advanced economic theorist, the author promises to go back to the drawing board and think deeply. He now has the time, as he has retired, or has at least been put out to pasture.

The first piece is on why onion prices are rising and second connecting economics to music:

This Note is intended to be of help to the millions of ordinary unlearned people who are wondering, in a battered sort of way, about the reasons for the sustained rise in the price of onions which we are now witnessing. A first step towards uncovering causation resides in considering the specifics of a closed, compact, convex, continuum economy in an epsilon environment characterised by almost-perfect autarky. A fuller picture is yielded by opening up the economy to world trade at border-prices, in which exchange at the margin is mediated by myopic discount rates. A good part of the burden of explanation would have to be borne by the operation of incomplete Arrow–Debreu contingent markets in an economy subjected to monetary sterilisation in the presence of debt-capitalisation; a steep and unprecedented increase in the repo rate; a failure to ensure anything more than partial convertibility on the capital account; insider trading on outward bills of lading; and quasi-transitive rationality on the part of agents experiencing animal spirits inspired by methylated spirits..

Hopefully you get the hang..

%d bloggers like this: