Is it fair for Governments to call people tax thieves? An analysis from Pakistan..

In many ways India is different from Pakistan and in many ways we are just similar. In India we are often told that how Indians don’t pay taxes. Same is the case in Pakistan too. Just that both countries don’t realise how much we are taxed from other sources. There is nothing here that is not taxed.

Shahid Mehmood an economist on Pakistan side of things:

WHAT’S the most depressing economic statistic that is churned out repetitively in Pakistan? It’s the number of taxpayers. Time and again, the government and donors embarrass us for doing our nation a huge disfavour. In his first address, Prime Minister Shahid Khaqan Abbasi lambasted Pakistanis for not paying taxes.

Yet these are just myths. The fact is, we are one of the most overtaxed nations in the world. Simple arithmetic will do. Let’s start with disproving the most widely quoted number: only 1.21 million citizens pay income tax, ie less than one per cent of the population. But statistics (like the State Bank of Pakistan annual report) suggest that there are more than 57.5m employed people in the country. Since they are employed, they must be earning something and incurring expenditures on goods and services.

There is no good or service in Pakistan that is tax-free. Therefore, around 58m people are paying income tax one way or the other since their expenditures obviously come from their income.

The same number can dispel another myth, that less than 1pc of Pakistan’s population pays taxes. Since Pakistan’s population is about 200m, the implication is that at least 29pc of the population is paying taxes. This number goes up when one considers the working-age population (15-59 years of age). As per the Economic Survey 2016-17, 61.4pc of the population is of working age, meaning around 122m people. The 58m people constitute approximately 48pc of this number.

Around 140m mobile-phone users pay more than 20pc tax on the total amount of load. By end 2015, the number of registered vehicles in Pakistan had surpassed 17m (and was growing). They run on fossil fuels, which are subjected to multiple taxes. The rate of sales tax on different goods and services is one of the highest in the world. Add to these the plethora of surcharges and duties, and what we have is a mind-boggling list of extractive and regressive methods of cheating people out of their earnings.

All these taxes are obviously extracted out of the income of those who earn. It is crass anti-intellectualism, then, to repeat the same old, tired mantra of ‘Pakistanis don’t pay taxes’.

From birth (all the expenses that parents bear before birth and at the time of birth) to death (burial places, in cities at least, are sold for a price), we are being excessively taxed. If the intangible taxes (negative spillover of poor governance like choked roads, polluted air and water, the absence of waste disposal, poor law and order, etc), are also brought into consideration, then the taxation burden quadruples.

Amen to that.

What is the main issue here?

Now that some mistaken taxation myths can safely be buried, we need to probe this issue further. Begin by asking two all-important questions: What exactly is our tax ‘problem’? And what kinds/forms of taxation policies do we need to implement? (Your answers need not be the same as mine.)

For policymakers, our ‘tax problem’ is that our revenues (around Rs3.8 trillion) are not enough to meet our expenditures (around Rs5tr). Wrong! Pakistan is not the only country where expenditures are more than revenues. Our issue stems from unproductive use of what’s at hand. If the expenditure is productive, then revenue shortages are not so debilitating since the expenditures generate increased revenue possibilities for the future.

Our ‘tax problem’, in short, is that we are poor at managing and judiciously using revenues. If we could productively use revenues half our revenues would not have been spent on paying interest on debt.

On to the second question, the answer to which would seem to be a rather settled issue in Pakistan. Everybody agrees that we need ‘progressive’ taxation, which in simple English implies taxing the rich more to redistribute. If that were to happen, would Pakistan be transformed? A probable answer comes from South Africa, which has the most progressive tax system in the world.

Yet the South African economy suffers from high income inequality. The reason is the absence of growth and quality-enhancing inclusive institutions. For example, like Pakistan, South Africa has a poor public education system, an institution that is critically important in stimulating economic growth and improving life quality in the long run. Other such institutions (such as research and development culture) are almost nonexistent in Pakistan.

So, no, progressive taxation is not going to automatically transform Pakistan into Disneyland. We need to have inclusive institutions and avenues through which tax expenditures can generate growth and an enhanced quality of life. In Pakistan’s case, these institutions are either missing or non-functional or in a sorry state. Thus, the mechanism for transforming tax expenditures into something meaningful is absent.

Not surprisingly, the growth of tax revenue from a mere Rs7.5 billion in 1972 to a colossal Rs3.8tr in 2017 has never proved enough for the ever-growing leviathan, which seeks even more without any clear plan for its productive use. What’s the guarantee that if tax revenues touch the required Rs5tr mark, unproductive expenditures would not gallop to Rs7tr?

Does all this imply that Pakistanis don’t indulge in evading taxes? No. A certain percentage of Pakistanis, just like any other country in the world, do evade taxes. But that’s not the issue, which is about why people do so. After all, the same people give out more than Rs400bn in charity every year. What gives? Obviously, those who contribute profusely towards charity believe that it will earn rewards (in the afterlife). The same expectation of reciprocity is absent in the case of paying taxes.

I will bring this article to a close by addressing the respected prime minister. Dear sir, instead of calling us tax thieves, you should have thanked the Pakistani nation for not having risen up and burned down the rent-seeking edifice that goes by the name of government. Please understand that to realise more taxes, you need to build trust with the people. Once you earn their trust, the apple (taxes) will automatically fall into your lap.

Strong words indeed!

How little we question this continuous narrative from the governments worldwide. The same dishonest people which on being elected become honest government and call people as tax thieves?

The real issue is why the government has higher expenditure. And why it keeps rising seeing no visible improvements in public goods? Much of fiscal responsibility is on controlling deficits with attention on raising more and more revenues. There should be rules/targets on expenditure too…

7 Responses to “Is it fair for Governments to call people tax thieves? An analysis from Pakistan..”

  1. Linkfest - Kairos Capital Says:

    […] Mostly Economics – Why do governments call the public tax thieves […]

  2. Anantha Nageswaran Says:

    Excellent post. The truth is there on both sides. Do governments over tax because too few pau or is it the other way around? Also, do governments overtax because there is so much leakage and wastage of revenues? There is truth in that too. Then, there are too many ad hoc exemptions which narrow the tax base. The base is then over taxed.

    Then, there is the tax administration too which starts with the presumption of evasion and criminality. Much to change on the government’s attitudes.

    • Amol Agrawal Says:

      Truth is on both sides. But I think people do react positively to more shown in them and reciprocate. Indian state for a long time has always mistrusted its people. The first principle is that all these guys are thieves and as a State I am this lone honest body. I think Indian businesses have been too coy about this and do not oppose the governments strongly enough. If the government thinks all are thieves, it it can close everything and is free to run the show. The 1990s did change this image and businesses were respected. It was best seen in Hindi movies where earlier villains were business who were mostly smuggling things. And post 90s, most heroes came from business families. But we are again stirring the same narrative. If this was not enough, now the neighbors are asked to join in the all our thieves agenda:

  3. Anantha Nageswaran Says:

    I would like to continue my comments. If one looks at the way Synergy-Dooray had gamed the bankruptcy resolution or, in general, how promoters have prospered at the expense of their companies, minority shareholders, of banks, etc., one has to concede that the societal moral and ethical foundations too are legitimate targets for scrutiny. So, there is much blame to go around and much soul searching to be done by many stakeholders.

    The answers are always not EITHER/OR but AND. Who would take the intiative hoping that the other side would play ball? Where is the trust factor to make that happen? I don’t have the answers. I find the challenges daunting.

  4. Says:

    Wһen you elect to freeⅼance, you wіll also be in controⅼ ⲟf your individᥙal schedule.

    Instead of being bound to the 9-to-five work dayy of ost law placеs of work, each your day by day schedսle and
    your calendar as a whole will likely be largely
    uup tо you. Whether youll want to take day off, or whether or
    not you ԝant tⲟ take оn a heavier workload, freelancing will meet your needs.

  5. pakistan Says:

    I am really happy to glance at this blog posts which contains plenty of
    valuable facts, thanks for providing these kinds of information.

  6. Jeffrey Liakos Says:

    Governments are the biggest tax thieves.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: