Pakistan just becoming a nation of traders…

Umair Jawed in Dawn writes on how Pakistan is slipping into premature deindustrialisation and becoming a country of traders:

THE Pakistan Business Council’s (PBC) recent report, titled Pakistan: Rising Imports, Declining Exports & Premature Deindustrialisation, provides careful documentation of three worrying macroeconomic trends. Two of these (imports and exports) receive considerable attention in policy and journalistic conversations, to the extent that Pakistan’s economic performance is often equated with the health of its external sector. However, the third, ie the spectre of deindustrialisation, remains significantly underreported and understudied.

The term premature deindustrialisation has most commonly been used to describe the structural trajectory of African economies after the 1970s. Many countries on the continent developed local manufacturing capacity under statist strategies during the first couple of decades after decolonisation, only to see domestic industry wither under inefficiencies, exogenous shocks, and a liberalised global trade regime. In subsequent years, the ravages of that period have pushed domestic surplus capital towards the services sector, further limiting the growth of manufacturing.

While there are important differences between these economies and Pakistan’s — most notably the time period during which industrial stagnation has set in — the aspect of a lethargic industrial base deserves further attention. Data shows the manufacturing sector’s percentage share in the economy falling consistently, from 14.5 per cent in 2007 to 13.5pc in 2017. This decline is driven by the worrying state of large-scale manufacturing, which has fallen from 12.3pc to 10.7pc over the same decade.

It is not a coincidence that this regression has taken place in a context marked by growing imports and negative trade balances with all major trading partners. Put simply, Pakistan ends up importing a whole host of goods instead of making them at home, while preferentially skewed trade agreements with many countries ensures this pattern stays in place.

Decline in industry has been replaced by rise in services:

In light of its declining industrial base, Pakistan’s structural transformation over this period has been in the direction of an expanding services sector, which now stands at nearly 60pc of the total economy. The largest sub-component within services, and now the single biggest sub-component in the entire economy, is retail-wholesale trade, which stands at 19pc of GDP. In 2017, this sector grew by 6.8pc thanks in no small part to the population’s unceasing propensity to consume, which has pushed private consumption to an all-time high of 80pc of GDP. The comparable figures from India, Bangladesh, and Indonesia are 60.8pc, 70pc, and 36pc respectively.

The onward march of pervasive consumption has been driven in large parts by easier access to im­­ported products, rising incomes, and greater urbanisation. Similarly, the myriad problems encountered while running manufacturing enterprises also make it simpler and quicker to earn money through lower-effort sectors like real estate and trading. Little surprise then that some of the most well-known industrial conglomerates in Pakistan have branched out into the services sector by building glossy shopping malls, running hotels, or selling burgers and cappuccinos to urban consumers. This consumerist upsurge is starkly visible in the built fabric of both major ur­­ban centres, which continue to expand in the shape of suburban housing schemes full of new commercial areas, as well as of smaller towns and cities across the country.

Consumption is 80% of GDP? That is just too high…Should check the figures..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: