Argentina’s economists fined for giving different inflation numbers

This is an amusing story (HT: Tyler Cowen) from the Latin American (just when someone praised the region) country.

The private sector economists say actual inflation higher than published figure…

Argentina’s government has filed criminal charges against the managers of an economic consulting firm, escalating its persecution of independent economists. …The government is charging MyS Consultores with “publishing false information about inflation data” to benefit themselves and their clients. The criminal complaint alleges that MyS’s data also lead to speculative behavior in Argentina’s bond market.

…Consumer prices rose 9.7% in May from a year ago, according to the national statistics agency, Indec. But virtually all economists say annual inflation surpasses 20%—one of the world’s highest rates—angering government officials who dismiss inflation as a problem.

A friend from Argentina also told me the same thing of inflation higher than 20%. So an interesting case of published inflaiton vs actual inflation. And what a way to defend the published figures – just fine them.

So far this year, the Secretariat has fined at least nine economic research firms 500,000 pesos ($122,000) each. This week, the Secretariat also slapped a second fine on Orlando J Ferreres & Asociados.

“They fine us for saying how much prices have risen,” Mr. Ferreres, director of his eponymous firm, said. “They could seek criminal charges against all of us. We don’t know how far they’re willing to go.”

Mr. Ferreres said the legal actions are part of a strategy to prevent independent economists from publishing potentially negative information during an election year…

Government officials say they hoped the fines would deter economists from “deceiving” the public into making poor financial decisions by publishing inflation estimates that differ considerably from Indec’s consumer price index.

Economists fight back:

Economists point to unrestrained fiscal spending, a booming economy and an expanding money supply as the main drivers of inflation that is at least double that reported by Indec. They also say the government tacitly admits to high inflation every time it backs collective-bargaining agreements that include annual wage increases of 20% to 30%

Amusing but startling as well. Instead of clarifying the facts, government chooses to punish the economists.

In India (and I assume other developing economies), we always feel actual inflation is higher than the published one. But we have never really figured how high the actual inflation is. Argentina guys have figured that out and what a treatment for finding the truth…

But then as they say Truth always prevails.. This has been the experience with most economics things. Officials may hide actual inflation figures, overstate growth etc but it does face reality sometime later… Let’ s see what prevails in Argentina…

5 Responses to “Argentina’s economists fined for giving different inflation numbers”

  1. Tygodniowy przegląd wiadomości ze świata: 18-24.07 | Exignorant's Blog Says:

    […] Ekonomiści argentyńscy dostają grzywny za podanie odmiennych wartości inflacji […]

  2. Tygodniowy przegląd ważnych wiadomości ze świata: 18-24.07 | Exignorant's Blog Says:

    […] Ekonomiści argentyńscy dostają grzywny za podanie odmiennych wartości inflacji […]

  3. News Links, July 22, 2011 | ARTs COLOURs Says:

    […] News Links, July 22, 2011 Posted on July 28, 2011 by candra ## Global economic meltdown ##Greek Deal Likely to Involve Bond Exchange “Euro-zone leaders are debating a new bailout package for Greece will likely include new rescue loans of roughly €70 billion (.51 billion) and a program to exchange much of Greece’s outstanding bond debt for new, 30-year bonds, people familiar with the talks said.” Bank Levy Plan Dropped From Greek Bailout Eurozone leaders draw up radical plan to safeguard euro The Fatal Flaw In Europe’s Second “Bazooka” Bailout: 82 Million Soon To Be Very Angry Germans, Or How Euro Bailout #2 Could Cost Up To 56% Of German GDP Euro Leaders Start Crisis Talks as Juncker Says Greek Default Is Possible Greece Threatened with Widespread, Long-Term Poverty“Greece is tightening its belt — and the number of people living in poverty is surging as a result. Thousands line up in front of food banks and resort to rifling through rubbish bins. The country’s financial crisis is rapidly turning into a social one — while wealthy tax evaders manage to get off scot-free.” Euro-Zone Growth Slows “The euro zone’s economy slowed sharply in July, as activity in the private sector barely expanded, according to a survey of purchasing managers in manufacturing and services.” EuroZone Manufacturing Barely Above Contraction David Morgan on Silver Price Manipulation, Delivery Default & Supply Shortage Risks (Chris Martenson) Audit: Fed gave trillion in emergency loans “The U.S. Federal Reserve gave out .1 trillion in emergency loans to U.S. and foreign financial institutions between Dec. 1, 2007 and July 21, 2010, according to figures produced by the government’s first-ever audit of the central bank. “Last year, the gross domestic product of the entire U.S. economy was .5 trillion.” Argentina’s economists fined for giving different inflation numbers […]

  4. How Argentina is pressurising McDonalds to price its Burger lower « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] never refuses to surprise. Its policymakers  have been making all kinds of  attempts to report lower than actual […]

  5. Why Argentina keeps going downhill… « Mostly Economics Says:

    […] then, it has been just one issue after the other. The one on how Arg reports lower inflation numbers and threatens those who report higher numbers is just so scary. Rogoff points this is to ensure the […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: